Archive for December, 2001

Controlling the Choke Points

Friday, December 21st, 2001

Given the Bush administration’s fondness for corporate interests and its disdain for enforcing laws designed to enhance competition, it seems likely that Comcast, the Philadelphia-based cable-TV company, will be permitted to buy AT&T’s cable and broadband unit (AP). Given the natural inclinations of business people, it seems equally likely that customers of these companies will end up considerably less satisfied than shareholders.

The current thinking among the people in charge is that technology moves so quickly that oligopolies, duopolies or even monopolies are constantly under threat. That logic is contrary to the practical reality, notably in the Microsoft situation, but it’s now federal policy.

So we’re on the verge of a new consolidation wave in telecommunications. We’ll end up with oligopolies, at best, in the key industries of the 21st Century.

Yes, you should be unhappy that you’ll pay higher prices to mega-companies that have less competition to worry about. You should recognize a more subtle threat — the decreasing diversity in the mass media, the news and programming that reaches the vast majority of Americans.

It’s worrisome enough that a few big corporations produce most of the news and entertainment people receive today. Now consider how things may be when two or at most three companies could soon control the digital access points to knowledge and entertainment.

This is what the mergers are about. Control the choke points and you win.

I’m not talking about you, of course. You’re just the customer, one of those folks who’ll feel the choking.

Comments

Wireless Breaks Out

Thursday, December 20th, 2001

  • Glenn Fleishmann: Public Space Wi-Fi’s Transforming Event. Boingo will build no hot spots. Instead, they are aggregating the network infrastructure of other companies and wrapping it up through a single user account, a single bill, and a single set of pricing. Dayton summarized the new firm’s thrust: “Boingo Wireless is a non- infrastructure wireless ISP.”
  • Alan Reiter: Earthlink’s nationwide wireless LAN business and cellular. Will Boingo Wireless adversely affect the plans of cellular operators to create “wireless Internet” demand for their next-generation networks? The short answer: No short- term affect, but there could be trouble ahead for the cellular carriers.

    I think this is likely to be a big deal over time, though the price strikes me as a bit high. More on this later.

    Comments

  • Blogging Recognition

    Wednesday, December 19th, 2001

    Dave Winer and his UserLand Software colleagues think bloggers deserve their own awards, and was kind enough to nominate this weblog, among others, for one of them. I’m honored.

    I see that they’ve excluded the UserLand sites from consideration. That’s a good decision from an ethical viewpoint, but a shame in another respect — they deserve notice in several categories.

    Comments

    Listening to Bill Clinton

    Wednesday, December 19th, 2001

    At the World Economic Forum annual meeting in early 2000, then-President Bill Clinton gave a speech of clarity and common sense — embracing globalization but warning that globalization had to occur with less secrecy and more inclusion of the have-nots. Many of the Americans at the meeting wondered in sadness where this president had been for eight years, and why he’d squandered what should have been a great presidency with lies, sleaze and — worst of all — the unwillingness to take real risks in service of larger goals.

    That memory has returned twice in the past few weeks, after reading transcripts of two powerful speeches by a man whose lost opportunities will surely haunt him for the rest of his days.

    Optimism in the face of deep problems shines through both speeches. But both make the absolutely crucial point that winning the war against Al Quaeda, while essential, is not enough. We in the developed world must bring our wealth to bear on the problems of those who languish or suffer in poverty and hopelessness elsewhere.

    Here are the transcripts:

  • Clinton’s address at Georgetown University on Nov. 7.
  • An address entitled The Struggle for the Soul of the 21st Century, given for Britain’s annual Dimbleby Lecture last week.

    See also:

  • Lance Knobel: Deja Vu. It’s sad, whatever you may have thought of Clinton’s presidency, to see how rapidly ex-political leaders become superfluous, even when they are young and intelligent. Of American presidents, only Jimmy Carter
  • A Bad Broadband Bill Delayed

    Wednesday, December 19th, 2001

    American telecommunications customers dodged a bullet last week when the House of Representatives postponed a vote on a broadband telecom bill that would have done more harm than good. But moneyed interests will be back to push this terrible legislation next year.

    More in my Wednesday column.

    Comments

    Microsoft Won’t Listen

    Wednesday, December 19th, 2001

    Dave Winer: Killer apps and blockbuster OSes. I’d like to recommend XP. Can you take out the phone-home features, and just ship a no-nonsense OS that isn’t all about DRM and doesn’t crash and supports modern Internet apps?

    The answer is surely No. An OS that doesn’t assume users are thieves is not in the cards from a company that has adopted control-freakery as one of its core tenets.

    Microsoft is well down the path to controlling tomorrow’s digital dial tone. From all appearances, it plans to put that domination into service of its own metasticizing businesses, the ambitions of which grow all the time. Microsoft is also becoming a key ally for the control freaks in the entertainment industry and, I’m convinced, government.

    Ease up? That would seem to violate the very foundation of the uber-strategy.

    Microsoft always listens. It occasionally does the right thing, but only when that fits comfortably into the larger plan.

    Comments

    Segway and its Meaning

    Tuesday, December 18th, 2001

    I love new gadgets, as much for what they imply as what they do themselves. The Apple Newton was wasn’t a great PDA, because it didn’t fit into a pocket, but it told us what was coming.

    That’s my reaction to the Segway, the powered scooter that has gotten so much press. It’s more important, IMO, for what it means than what it is.

    More in my special Monday column.

  • See also this excellent essay by Dan Bricklin.

    Comments

  • Zzzzzzz

    Tuesday, December 18th, 2001

    Forgive the several days between postings. I’ve been in bed with a not-too-bad case of the flu (or something else that gives me headaches, chills and general malaise), and it’s been hard to concentrate on more than chicken soup and an occasional TV program.

    Feeling more ambulatory today, however, or at least a little less hazy.

    Comments

    Independent Web News

    Tuesday, December 18th, 2001

    JD Lasica: Independents Day. When it comes to Net news, small can be beautiful.

    This is an excellent look at four independent news-oriented Web sites. I’m a huge fan of Kuro5hin and MetaFilter, and didn’t know much about IWantMedia until I read JD’s story.

    But I have to agree with Doc’s analysis of KenRadio. There’s plenty of talent in this site and what it represents, but the way it’s presented leaves a great deal to be desired.

    Comments

    Internet’s Promise, or Not

    Friday, December 14th, 2001

    Don’t know how I missed it, but Jennifer Balderama wrote an excellent piece on “Where Internet promises remain unfulfilled” — and sparked a lively discussion among Doc, Mike and others in the blogging community.

    Comments